Closing Bell

Closing Bell

2020 will be forever remembered as the year of the virus with the fastest and deepest recession the world has ever seen.

A year like no other

2020 will be forever remembered as the year of the virus with the fastest and deepest recession the world has ever seen. A year in which investors have been challenged with unprecedented forces, where medical data was more influential than economic data and a closely fought US presidential election was overshadowed by vaccine trial results. Above and beyond all of these has been the terrible human cost in terms lives lost or damaged.

The year began rather quietly. Economic data releases around the world in January were solid if unspectacular. There was much talk of recession in the US over the holiday period but there was no real evidence in the data or from company reports. In the UK, a mini housing boom was developing, following Boris Johnson’s stunning electoral victory and the successful passage of the Brexit Withdrawal Agreement. Chinese economic data were solid and even Europe seemed to be growing steadily. Despite worrying tensions between the US and China, markets were relatively calm.

Graph with data

Then the virus struck. As it swept across the globe, large swathes of the economy were closed down by government diktat. Numbers of new cases and fatalities from the virus led the national news in just about every country. Stock markets tumbled. Policymakers, with memories of the global financial crisis fresh in their minds, took actions that were big, bold and decisive. Never before has such massive economic stimulus been delivered so quickly. Huge increases in government spending, tax cuts and loan guarantees were combined with central bank intervention that went far beyond the traditional boundaries.

Forecasters were slow to recognise the scale of the recession and equally slow to appreciate the speed and scale of the bounce back. Charts of economic surprises, showing the degree to which releases differ from consensus expectations, went from record weakness to record strength. But equity markets were ahead of forecasters and began to recover at the end of March following action by the Federal Reserve and the reversal of technical selling.
This was followed by optimism that virus could be successfully suppressed. In China, new cases had fallen to very low levels; fresh outbreaks of the virus were isolated and swiftly dealt with. Lockdowns were eased and economic activity was recovering rapidly. By the summer, Europe appeared to be following a similar path. The US was having less success but the path to virus suppression seemed clear. That has now changed: China is the exception rather than the rule and the virus is once again threatening renewed recession even before economies had have yet to fully recovered from the last one. Yet the vaccine has brought genuine hope that the virus will be beaten, and that economic activity can recover fully during the course of next year.
Financial markets have been dominated by these events. There has been wide divergence in returns across asset classes, within equities and at different times in the year. MSCI World equites may have returned some 13% year-to-date but by 23 March they had lost 38% of their value at the start of the year. Since then they have almost doubled. Limiting risk in the first period and adding to it in the second was the key to performance. Another, rather simpler, strategy was to buy and hold the familiar US mega-cap growth stocks. They outperformed during the bear market and the upswing, a rare phenomenon. Tesla was one of the most outstanding examples of the tech theme and now has a market cap of $0.6 trillion, roughly the same as the combined market cap of all other auto companies combined. $100 invested in the shares at the start of 2013 would now be worth $9,000.

Our portfolio managers commented that there were few bids on the way down and few offers on the way up. Yet new issuance this year has broken records.

One of the strongest supports for risk assets has been the decline in real interest rates: the yield on 10-year US Treasury Inflation Protected Securities declined by a full percentage point in 2019, and with a similar fall this year, now offers little more than -1% a year. Yields on their UK counterparts have also declined dramatically with the added spice of a proposed redefinition of the inflation index.
Massive uncertainty and negative yields boosted gold, which has outperformed most commodities, with copper and iron ore being exceptions. This in turn reflects the fact that this year’s recession has been focused on services, with manufacturing relatively unaffected and construction enjoying a boom in many countries – the reverse of the normal pattern in recession. Oil prices were one of the weakest commodities.

By comparison, bond markets appear to have been havens of stability, in terms of the year-to-date returns shown in the chart. Yet they had their own excitement. The corporate bond market came close to collapse in March, saved by a huge effort on the part of the Federal Reserve. Our portfolio managers commented that there were few bids on the way down and few offers on the way up. Yet new issuance this year has broken records. Even the US Treasury market, the most liquid bond market in the world, went into convulsion in March with yields at the very long end of the curve gyrating violently. The world’s biggest buyers of government bonds have been central banks, turning conventional views of financial stability on their heads.

Throughout all this, most people have seen their lives, personal and professional, turned upside down. Medical science has come to the rescue in the most remarkable way. The world may never be the same again but 2021 should see a return to something much closer to normality. May I wish you all a happy festive period. But as the New Year approaches, I hope the reader will forgive me for saying ‘good riddance to 2020’.
Steven Bell
Steven Bell
Chief Economist, EMEA

Steven Bell is a Managing Director, responsible for providing macro strategy input to a broader range of multi asset investment portfolios. He joined Columbia Threadneedle through the acquisition of BMO GAM (EMEA) in 2021, having previously been with BMO since 2013. He joined the group having run the GLC’s Global Macro programme for the previous seven years. Before that he was Global Chief Economist and Investment Head of the UK multi asset business at Deutsche Asset Management during his tenure 1984 – 2005. Steven began his career as an Economic Adviser at the UK Treasury and has degrees in economics from the London School of Economics and Stanford University, California.

Steven Bell
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on email

Key topics

Risk Disclaimer

Past performance is not a guide to future performance. The value of investments and any income derived from them can go down as well as up and investors may not get back the original amount invested.

The information, opinions, estimates or forecasts contained in this document were obtained from sources reasonably believed to be reliable and are subject to change at any time.

Team member placeholder


Legal and regulatory disclosures

For professional clients and/or qualified investors only

Nothing on this website is, or is intended to be, an offer, advice, or an invitation to buy or sell any investments, in any jurisdiction where, or to anyone whom it would be unlawful to do so. Please read our full terms and conditions before proceeding further with any investment product referred to on this website. This website may not be suitable for everyone, and if you are at all unsure whether an investment product referenced on this website will meet your individual needs, please seek professional advice before proceeding further with such product. I have read and accept the terms and conditions and cookie policy of this site.