How ‘ESG’ is Bitcoin?

How ‘ESG’ is Bitcoin?

Discover what positive and negative ESG issues apply to Bitcoin and whether the cryptocurrency is a responsible investment.

Bitcoin has generated plenty of headlines owing to its volatile nature, most recently thanks to Tesla’s purchase of $1.5 billion worth of the stock and subsequent comments from Elon Musk. Now the news attention is turning to focus more on the cryptocurrency’s significant energy use – the Guardian being one such news outlet to report that Bitcoin mining consumes more energy than entire countries. So we consider…for those who wish to invest responsibly with environmental, social and governance (ESG) considerations at the forefront, is this technology suitable?

Before we get into it, let’s define what Bitcoin actually is. It is a digital currency (or ‘cryptocurrency’) that offers lower transaction fees than traditional online payment methods. Unlike government-issued currencies (the British pound, US dollar etc), it is operated by a decentralised authority. Learn more here.

Bitcoin’s potentially positive ESG factors…

On the surface, the proposition from Bitcoin to democratise financial markets by removing intermediaries certainly does have its social advantages. For example, reducing the cost of remittance corridors between richer and poorer countries, through which migrant workers send funds home to their families, feature within the UN’s Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). In addition, the anonymity that Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies provides can give security to those under oppressive regimes or provide a level of privacy to users that is being eroded in these digital times.

…versus its negative ESG factors

This decentralised monetary model reliant upon advanced cryptography comes at a significant environmental cost. As widely reported, Bitcoin’s estimated annual power consumption matches that of various countries around the world; recent analysis from Digiconomist puts Bitcoin’s annual energy consumption just behind that of Chile. More significantly, with two-thirds of mining taking place in coal-heavy regions like China where energy costs are subsidised, the resultant carbon footprint is huge. Over the long term, it is difficult to see how this is consistent with a transition to a low carbon economy.

In addition, Bitcoin needs to work on shedding its shady reputation amongst financial regulators that its design prioritising anonymity means it has historically been used online to facilitate money laundering and financed criminal activity that undermines social institutions. Just last month headlines such as this one by The Times reported European Central Bank President Christine Lagarde’s call for regulation to address ‘funny business’ associated with the cryptocurrency. Although still not anywhere near as significant as the use of conventional cash for these purposes in the offline world today, its use as a digital currency used predominately online makes this comparison seen as less relevant to these gate-keepers. This is changing as more transactions take place on formal exchanges that have anti-money laundering and “Know Your Customer” (KYC) procedures in place, but recent comments by the Biden administration show that this opinion remains a headwind.

Our verdict

All of this is to say that, overall, we consider Bitcoin, and other cryptocurrencies, to be a net negative from an ESG standpoint. As it currently stands, the positive potential of Bitcoin remains unproven, but the negatives are very real and present.
Yet that is not necessarily the end of the story, as we consider that the blockchain technology that underpins cryptocurrencies has a lot more promise at providing solutions to long-standing ESG problems. By offering a new method to record information in a manner that is more open while also being secure, it could address issues with supply chain traceability, renewable energy distribution, anti-money laundering and proxy voting. It might not grab the headlines in the way that its cryptocurrency cousins have done so before it, but in the background (or rather back-office) and behind the scenes, it could provide exciting opportunities in helping companies tackle the sustainability issues that their businesses face.

Interested in discovering more about how blockchain works, its advantages and ESG applications? LEARN MORE

5
unstructured
David Sneyd
David Sneyd
Vice President, Responsible Investment

David joined the Responsible Investment team in 2017 and has over 13 years of ESG experience. Prior to joining the firm David was ESG Manager at Fidelity International, responsible for their ESG integration programme, having previously held senior research positions at the governance research agencies ISS and PIRC. David has extensive experience with a European and US coverage on researching ESG topics, engaging with companies at a board/senior management level and dialoguing with policy makers. In addition he has been involved in integrating ESG themes into the investment research and decision-making processes. He has the Investment Management Certificate (IMC) from the CFA Society. He also holds a BA in Philosophy from Sussex University and an MSc in Philosophy and Public Policy from the London School of Economics.

David Sneyd
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on email

Key topics

Risk Disclaimer

The value of investments and any income derived from them can go down as well as up and investors may not get back the original amount invested.

Views and opinions have been arrived at by Columbia Threadneedle Management Limited and should not be considered to be a recommendation or solicitation to buy or sell any companies that may be mentioned.

The information, opinions, estimates or forecasts contained in this document were obtained from sources reasonably believed to be reliable and are subject to change at any time.

Team member placeholder

...

Legal and regulatory disclosures

For professional clients and/or qualified investors only

Nothing on this website is, or is intended to be, an offer, advice, or an invitation to buy or sell any investments, in any jurisdiction where, or to anyone whom it would be unlawful to do so. Please read our full terms and conditions before proceeding further with any investment product referred to on this website. This website may not be suitable for everyone, and if you are at all unsure whether an investment product referenced on this website will meet your individual needs, please seek professional advice before proceeding further with such product. I have read and accept the terms and conditions and cookie policy of this site.

Please confirm a few details about yourself to visit your preference centre

*Mandatory fields

Something went wrong, please try again

Thank you. You can now visit your preference centre to choose which insights you would like to receive by email.

To view and control which insights you receive from us by email, please visit your preference centre.